I totally get it, navigating the library stacks for a new thriller can feel impossible, and we all need a guaranteed page-turner to clear the nightstand pile. If you’re looking for something intensely dark, J.D. Barker has become one of my favorite authors, and here’s what I think about his unsettling novel, The Fifth to Die. If you’re a fan of J.D. Barker’s writing style, you know he delivers relentless suspense, and let me help you find your next great read so you don’t waste time on a dud.
The Fourth Monkey (A 4MK Thriller) by J. D. Barker
What’s This Book About? (Quick Summary)
This is the origin story that kicks off the whole 4MK saga. Detective Porter is hunting a killer whose victims are linked by the “See No Evil, Hear No Evil, Speak No Evil” concept, sending out body parts in white boxes. It’s a genius and deeply disturbing premise that hooks you instantly and sets a terrifying tone for the entire series.
My Honest Take on The Fourth Monkey (A 4MK Thriller) by J. D. Barker
I snagged this paperback edition at the airport, and my flight felt like five minutes long. Seriously, J.D. Barker really establishes his signature dark, meticulous style here. If you haven’t read any of Barker’s work yet, this is the one to grab first because it lays the necessary groundwork for the rest of the series. The concept, which plays off the three wise monkeys, is so clever and instantly chilling; I kept thinking about it long after I finished reading. What Barker does brilliantly is he gives you the killer’s perspective through diary entries, which adds a terrifying layer of intimacy to the horrifying events. While the pacing is a little slower initially than The Fifth to Die, Barker uses that time to build an unforgettable atmosphere and introduces you to Detective Porter, who is a perfectly flawed hero. Honestly, this is one of the best mystery books I’ve read recently, and it definitely convinced me to become a lifelong fan of Barker.
What I Loved:
The structure is amazing, switching between Porter’s current investigation and the killer’s unsettling diary entries. I loved the meticulous detail Barker used when building the killer’s psychological profile.
What Didn’t Work For Me:
There’s a lot of world-building here, which means the initial pace feels slightly slower than the subsequent books. But honestly, I’m nitpicking here, because it’s totally necessary.
Bottom Line: Absolutely start here if you want to understand the 4MK killer’s motivation and get introduced to Detective Porter.
[CTA_BUTTON_X]
The Fifth to Die (A 4MK Thriller) by J.D. Barker
What’s This Book About? (Quick Summary)
This book takes place shortly after the events of the first, with Porter still reeling from the hunt for 4MK when a new, bizarre string of murders surfaces, all tied to ritualistic bathing and specific phases of the moon. It’s high stakes, forcing Porter to confront his past and dive back into the terrifying darkness he thought he had escaped.
My Honest Take on The Fifth to Die by J.D. Barker
I picked up the hardcover edition of this one because I knew I’d want to keep it on my bookshelf, and thank goodness I did because I absolutely tore through it. Detective Porter is back, and honestly, he’s such a beautifully broken character, struggling with everything that happened in the last book. J.D. Barker does an amazing job pulling you right back into the relentless, horrifying world, even though the central crimes are different this time. The pacing in this installment felt faster than The Fourth Monkey. I stayed up way too late reading this; I needed to know how the victims were connected and what new twisted game was being played out. What hooked me was the complex psychological tension, Barker manages to make the twists genuinely surprising, not just cheap thrills. You really feel the weight of Porter’s personal life crashing down while he chases this deeply disturbing new murderer.
What I Loved:
The shift in focus to a new, equally disturbing killer while still referencing the trauma of 4MK was brilliant. I also loved the intense
What Didn’t Work For Me:
There were a couple of secondary character subplots that I felt detracted slightly from the main intensity of the hunt, but they were minor interruptions overall.
Bottom Line: This is a crucial, high-stakes entry that maintains the intense dark energy established by Barker in the first book.
[CTA_BUTTON_X]
The Sixth Wicked Child by J.D. Barker
What’s This Book About? (Quick Summary)
This is the culmination of the 4MK trilogy, bringing everything full circle and escalating the personal stakes for Porter to an almost unbearable degree. The mystery deepens, the scope widens, and all the loose ends and secondary characters start tying together in explosive ways.
My Honest Take on The Sixth Wicked Child by J.D. Barker
Look, when I started this series, I didn’t think J.D. Barker could ratchet up the tension anymore, but here we are. This book felt like the real emotional climax for Detective Porter, and if you thought the first two books were dark, prepare yourself. I almost gave up around chapter 3 because the content is so intense and unsettling, but I’m so glad I didn’t push through because the character development Barker delivers here is fantastic. You know that feeling when you’re reading a massive twist, and you physically gasp and drop your book? Yeah, that happened multiple times in this one. Barker uses the history and mythology of the villain brilliantly to explain the terrifying psychology behind the crimes, offering satisfying answers while still maintaining a deeply disturbing atmosphere. This is the book I would definitely bring to book club because the discussions it sparks about morality and obsession are endless.
What I Loved:
The way Barker managed to resolve complex plot lines that had been building for two books was masterful. The ending felt earned and incredibly satisfying, even if it left me emotionally drained.
What Didn’t Work For Me:
Because it is the final book, the pacing is absolutely relentless. You need to be prepared for zero breaks, which, while thrilling, can be exhausting for a casual read.
Bottom Line: If you’ve committed to the series, this finale by Barker is essential reading and delivers the satisfying closure you need.
[CTA_BUTTON_X]
J.D. Barker Collection 2 Books Set (The Fourth Monkey, The Fifth to Die)
What’s This Book About? (Quick Summary)
This is a fantastic set that bundles the first two books in the 4MK series: The Fourth Monkey and The Fifth to Die. It’s simply the quickest way to dive into Detective Porter’s world and understand the relentless darkness of J.D. Barker’s storytelling.
My Honest Take on J.D. Barker Collection 2 Books Set (The Fourth Monkey, The Fifth to Die) by J.D. Barker
Honestly, this collection is just smart shopping if you know you’re going to get hooked, and trust me, you will. I actually bought these two books separately, but if you’re gifting them or just starting out, grab the set! Since you get The Fourth Monkey and The Fifth to Die together, you get J.D. Barker’s amazing world-building right away without having to wait for the sequel to ship. I read the first one so fast, I was panicking that I didn’t have the next one immediately. It’s a great way to guarantee you have the next read ready when the first one ends at 2 AM. Barker’s writing works so well back-to-back, and I appreciate having a matching set on my bookshelf, even if mine are slightly dog-eared from my obsessive reading.
What I Loved:
Convenience, obviously. Getting two spectacular, intense thrillers by Barker in one purchase is just great value.
What Didn’t Work For Me:
You might lose two days of sleep because you won’t be able to stop reading, but that’s hardly a complaint about the books themselves!
Bottom Line: Buy this set if you are ready to binge a truly outstanding series by J.D. Barker.
[CTA_BUTTON_X]
Why The Fifth to Die Is Worth Reading
If you’re asking me which one of these amazing thriller books you should start with, the answer is always The Fourth Monkey, you need to understand the beginning to appreciate the psychological trauma Porter carries into the later books. However, if you’ve already read the first one and are wondering if the intensity holds up, let me tell you, The Fifth to Die is absolutely worth reading.
What makes The Fifth to Die special is how J.D. Barker manages to pivot the storyline. It would have been easy to just rehash the first book, but instead, Barker introduces a completely different type of horror, maintaining the relentless tension while pushing Detective Porter into new, darker territory. It focuses heavily on the character fallout of the first book’s events, making the story intensely personal and emotional. If you like procedural thrillers but want the depth of a character study, The Fifth to Die is phenomenal. Barker does an amazing job ensuring that the secondary investigation doesn’t feel like filler but an organic continuation of Porter’s spiral.
If I had to pick ONE book to bring to book club and discuss the finer points of psychological breakdown under extreme pressure, it would be The Fifth to Die. If you prefer the origin story and setup, grab The Fourth Monkey. But honestly, since the J.D. Barker Collection 2 Books Set is available, you should just grab that and guarantee yourself a week of sleepless reading!
The Fifth to Die Final Verdict
So, here’s my honest take: the 4MK series by J.D. Barker, and specifically The Fifth to Die, deserves a permanent spot on your bookshelf. This series is not for the faint of heart; it deals with genuinely disturbing themes and dark psychological content. If you are looking for thriller books that grab you by the throat on page one and don’t let go until the very last sentence, this is it. I’d love to hear which one you pick up first, but trust me, you’ll be texting me by chapter five wondering what the heck just happened.
The Fifth to Die FAQ
Do I need to read these in order?
Yes, absolutely. While The Fifth to Die introduces a new primary mystery, the continuous character arc of Detective Porter and the psychological hangover from the 4MK killer mean you really need to start with The Fourth Monkey to get the full emotional impact and understand all the references.
How long did it take you to read The Fifth to Die?
I read the physical copy of The Fifth to Die over a rainy weekend, maybe about 12 total hours, because I physically couldn’t put it down. These are dense books but the pacing is so quick they fly by.
Are there any content warnings for this thriller?
Yes, be aware that J.D. Barker does not shy away from dark content. There are strong themes of ritualized violence, murder, psychological torment, and intense trauma, so if you prefer lighter suspense, you might want to skip this one.
Is the hardcover worth it or should I get paperback?
I always recommend the hardcover for The Fifth to Die if you plan to keep it, because Barker’s books are definite keepers, and the large size makes the late-night reading sessions easier on the eyes. However, the paperback is much easier to travel with, especially if you get the two-book collection set.
What other books by J.D. Barker should I try?
If you finish the 4MK trilogy and need more, J.D. Barker also writes The Sixth Wicked Child and has some excellent collaborations. I’d suggest checking out The Cabin at the End of the World or some of his other standalone psychological thrillers if you want a break from Detective Porter.
Is The Fifth to Die good for thriller beginners?
Look, it’s a master class in the genre, but it is deeply dark. If you are a beginner, you might want to ease into the genre with something slightly less intense first, but if you jump right in, you will quickly learn what one of the best thriller books feels like.
chessmantras.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases made through our links.
